Lists of Analogies, Metaphors and Idioms for Lawyers
Posted by
Ken Lopez on Fri, Mar 16, 2012 @ 12:03 PM
by Ken Lopez
The task of a trial lawyer is to convince a judge or jury to believe in the truth of a client’s case. However, in many complex trials, the underlying facts are not as easily understood by the fact-finder as they would be in, say, a murder case or a traffic accident. A case, especially the type of litigation that we are involved in, often turns on complex issues of science, medicine, engineering, or some other subject that jurors and many judges are not well versed in.
How does a lawyer move from the arcane to the everyday and get jurors to follow along? Enter the metaphor, simile, or idiom.
We use these “figures of speech” all the time in conversation, often without realizing we are doing so. Whenever we say we need to “level the playing field” or “push the envelope” or “draw a line in the sand,” we are using a metaphor. When we say something is “as dull as dishwater” or “as slow as molasses,” we are using a simile. When we tell a friend to “break a leg” for good luck, we are using an idiom.
Briefly, a metaphor is a figure of speech that uses one thing to refer to another as a means of making a comparison between the two. A simile actually makes the comparison between two dissimilar things directly with the use of the word “like” or “as.” An idiom is an expression that is more than the sum of its parts (think “raining cats and dogs” or “spill the beans”); it is usually based on a metaphor, though the metaphor may be a bit “buried” after centuries of use. These figures of speech have one thing in common: They are all used as analogies, to compare one thing to another.
In a trial, a lawyer can use a metaphor to show the jury how something works or how an event occurred, based on an analogy to another thing or process that jurors know well from their everyday lives. For example, in an antitrust case, when describing how a group of competitors squeezed another company out of the market by denying it the opportunity to buy a needed product, the lawyer might tell the jury that the conspirators choked the life out of the other company as if they had denied it the air it needed to breathe.
Ray Moses of the Center for Criminal Justice Advocacy, a Texas-based nonpartisan, grassroots training resource that helps lawyers become competent criminal trial practitioners, writes well about analogies and metaphors.
“Jurors remember facts and concepts that are familiar to them or that can be analogized to familiar subjects,” Moses writes. “Those who aspire to be effective communicators and persuaders must learn to argue by analogy and to explain by stories. This is particularly true when we are seeking to clarify and tie together complex facts, abstract ideas, or legal concepts. If facts or legal issues become overcomplicated, jurors become overwhelmed. It is here that an appropriate analogy may assist the jury in comprehending the import of the evidence that has been dished out during testimony, assessing the credibility of the sources of evidence, and/or understanding the application of law to facts that are found to be true.”
Below are a number of websites that are useful in finding the best analogy, metaphor, similie or idiom to use in your case:
Below are some additional resources on the A2L Consulting site:
What others have had to say about this topic:
About A2L Consulting
• Leading national litigation consulting firm since 1995
• Personnel nationwide
• Routinely voted #1 for demonstrative evidence consulting, jury consulting or intellectual property litigation consulting nationally
• Consulted for all major law firms on 10,000+ cases with trillions of dollars cumulatively at stake offering:
Trial Consulting: mock trials, Micro-Mock™, mock Markman hearings, jury consulting, shadow juries, jury selection and more;
Trial Graphics: legal graphics and litigation graphics, courtroom animation, video, printed foam core trial exhibits, PowerPoint presentation consulting, simplifying the case story and more;
Trial Technology & Onsite Personnel: ebriefs (electronic briefs), hot seat operators, trial technicians, courtroom presentations and more;
Look for A2L trial consultants, graphics consultants and jury consultants in Washington, DC, Baltimore, MD, New York, NY, Boston, MA, Alexandria, VA, Atlanta, GA, Miami, FL, Chicago, IL, Houston, Texas, Los Angeles, CA, and San Francisco, California, Wilmington, Delaware, Philadelphia, PA, Phoenix, AZ, San Antonio, Palo Alto, Dallas, Detroit, Baltimore, Cleveland, Kansas City, Las Vegas, Pittsburgh, Richmond, VA, Salt Lake City, Denver, London, Dublin, Johannesburg, Brussels and many other cities and countries around the world. A2L Contact Information.
Claim a FREE Subscription to this Blog - The Litigation Consulting Report - Quarterly iPad Giveaways for Subscribers